perm filename NSCHRT.TEX[TIM,LSP] blob
sn#778681 filedate 1984-12-02 generic text, type C, neo UTF8
COMMENT ā VALID 00021 PAGES
C REC PAGE DESCRIPTION
C00001 00001
C00003 00002 \parskip .1in plus 5pt \baselineskip 15pt \lineskip 1pt
C00004 00003 $$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
C00008 00004 $$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
C00013 00005 $$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
C00018 00006 $$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
C00027 00007 $$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
C00032 00008 $$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
C00037 00009 $$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
C00042 00010 $$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
C00047 00011 $$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
C00052 00012 $$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
C00057 00013 $$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
C00062 00014 $$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
C00067 00015 $$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
C00076 00016 $$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
C00081 00017 $$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
C00086 00018 $$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
C00091 00019 $$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
C00096 00020 $$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
C00101 00021 $$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
C00103 ENDMK
Cā;
\parskip .1in plus 5pt \baselineskip 15pt \lineskip 1pt
\newbox\bigstrutbox
\setbox\bigstrutbox=\hbox{\vrule height9.6pt depth4.6pt width0pt}
\def\bigstrut{\relax\ifmmode\copy\bigstrutbox\else\unhcopy\bigstrutbox\fi}
These charts are the raw times as they were reported by the implementors.
The column headed {\bf CPU~$+$~GC} is computed for all implementations which
reported both CPU time and garbage collection time; InterLisp Vax~780
reported only CPU~$+$~garbage collection time.
All times are in seconds.
\vfill\eject
$$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
\def\tablerule{\noalign{\hrule}}
\halign {\bigstrut#& \vrule#\tabskip=1em plus2em&#& \vrule#&\hfil#\hfil&
\vrule#\tabskip=0pt\cr\tablerule
&&\multispan{3}\hfil {\bf Real Time} {\bf (Normalized)}\hfil&\cr
&&\multispan{3}{\hfil {\bf Boyer}}\hfil&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil {\bf Implementation}\hfil&&{\bf REAL}&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-Cray\hfil&&1.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-3081\hfil&&1.37&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil S-1\hfil&&2.99&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda (M-C)\hfil&&4.52&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil $3600+\hbox{IFU}$\hfil&&4.72&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 3600\hfil&&5.53&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil SAIL\hfil&&6.99&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-20\hfil&&7.01&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-HP200\hfil&&7.6&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 8600 CL\hfil&&7.88&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Dorado\hfil&&9.02&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda\hfil&&11.58&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-DN160\hfil&&12.21&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-780\hfil&&12.28&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil LM-2\hfil&&13.39&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil InterLisp-10\hfil&&15.75&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil InterLispVax 780\hfil&&15.86&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 785 CL\hfil&&17.45&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750 (VMS)\hfil&&18.75&\cr\tablerule
}}$$
\vfill\eject
$$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
\def\tablerule{\noalign{\hrule}}
\halign {\bigstrut#& \vrule#\tabskip=1em plus2em&#& \vrule#&\hfil#\hfil&
\vrule#\tabskip=0pt\cr\tablerule
&&\multispan{3}\hfil {\bf Real Time} {\bf (Normalized)}\hfil&\cr
&&\multispan{3}{\hfil {\bf Browse}}\hfil&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil {\bf Implementation}\hfil&&{\bf REAL}&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-3081\hfil&&1.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-Cray\hfil&&1.32&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil S-1\hfil&&1.62&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-20\hfil&&4.55&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil $3600+\hbox{IFU}$\hfil&&5.1&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda (M-C)\hfil&&6.07&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda\hfil&&6.26&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 3600\hfil&&6.61&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-HP200\hfil&&7.04&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-780\hfil&&7.97&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 8600 CL\hfil&&10.94&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil LM-2\hfil&&11.13&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil SAIL\hfil&&13.1&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750\hfil&&14.51&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Dorado\hfil&&14.96&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil InterLisp-10\hfil&&15.42&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750 (VMS)\hfil&&16.44&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil InterLispVax 780\hfil&&17.68&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 785 CL\hfil&&21.01&\cr\tablerule
}}$$
\vfill\eject
$$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
\def\tablerule{\noalign{\hrule}}
\halign {\bigstrut#& \vrule#\tabskip=1em plus2em&#& \vrule#&\hfil#\hfil&
\vrule#\tabskip=0pt\cr\tablerule
&&\multispan{3}\hfil {\bf Real Time} {\bf (Normalized)}\hfil&\cr
&&\multispan{3}{\hfil {\bf Destructive}}\hfil&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil {\bf Implementation}\hfil&&{\bf REAL}&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-Cray\hfil&&1.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil S-1\hfil&&2.07&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 8600 CL\hfil&&4.77&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-20\hfil&&5.41&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil $3600+\hbox{IFU}$\hfil&&6.05&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda (M-C)\hfil&&7.05&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 3600\hfil&&8.41&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-780\hfil&&8.8&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-HP200\hfil&&9.66&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 785 CL\hfil&&9.89&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda\hfil&&11.59&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil InterLispVax 780\hfil&&12.36&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 780 CL\hfil&&14.5&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Dorado\hfil&&16.32&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750\hfil&&16.41&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-DN160\hfil&&16.89&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750 (VMS)\hfil&&19.09&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil SAIL\hfil&&19.16&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil LM-2\hfil&&19.41&\cr\tablerule
}}$$
\vfill\eject
$$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
\def\tablerule{\noalign{\hrule}}
\halign {\bigstrut#& \vrule#\tabskip=1em plus2em&#& \vrule#&\hfil#\hfil&
\vrule#\tabskip=0pt\cr\tablerule
&&\multispan{3}\hfil {\bf Real Time} {\bf (Normalized)}\hfil&\cr
&&\multispan{3}{\hfil {\bf Traverse Initialization}}\hfil&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil {\bf Implementation}\hfil&&{\bf REAL}&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-3081\hfil&&1.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil S-1\hfil&&1.07&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 8600 CL\hfil&&3.4&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil $3600+\hbox{IFU}$\hfil&&4.02&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-20\hfil&&4.22&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 3600\hfil&&5.25&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda (M-C)\hfil&&6.47&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-HP200\hfil&&7.52&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 785 CL\hfil&&7.79&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-780\hfil&&8.37&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda\hfil&&11.06&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 780 CL\hfil&&11.53&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Dorado\hfil&&11.66&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil InterLispVax 780\hfil&&13.77&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-DN160\hfil&&16.58&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 780 Franz (TrlOn \& LclfNo)\hfil&&16.82&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750 (VMS)\hfil&&17.33&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 750 CL\hfil&&19.69&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750\hfil&&19.74&\cr\tablerule
}}$$
\vfill\eject
$$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
\def\tablerule{\noalign{\hrule}}
\halign {\bigstrut#& \vrule#\tabskip=1em plus2em&#& \vrule#&\hfil#\hfil&
\vrule#\tabskip=0pt\cr\tablerule
&&\multispan{3}\hfil {\bf Real Time} {\bf (Normalized)}\hfil&\cr
&&\multispan{3}{\hfil {\bf Traverse}}\hfil&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil {\bf Implementation}\hfil&&{\bf REAL}&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-3081\hfil&&1.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil SAIL\hfil&&2.42&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil S-1\hfil&&3.04&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil $3600+\hbox{IFU}$\hfil&&3.59&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 8600 CL\hfil&&4.11&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-20\hfil&&4.44&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 3600\hfil&&5.07&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda (M-C)\hfil&&5.32&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-DN160\hfil&&5.68&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Dorado\hfil&&6.46&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-780\hfil&&7.32&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 780 Franz (TrlOn \& LclfNo)\hfil&&8.39&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil InterLisp-10\hfil&&8.68&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 785 CL\hfil&&10.86&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-HP200\hfil&&10.99&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 750 Franz (TrlOn \& LclfNo)\hfil&&13.41&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda\hfil&&14.01&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750 (VMS)\hfil&&14.83&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 780 CL\hfil&&16.35&\cr\tablerule
}}$$
\vfill\eject
$$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
\def\tablerule{\noalign{\hrule}}
\halign {\bigstrut#& \vrule#\tabskip=1em plus2em&#& \vrule#&\hfil#\hfil&
\vrule#\tabskip=0pt\cr\tablerule
&&\multispan{3}\hfil {\bf Real Time} {\bf (Normalized)}\hfil&\cr
&&\multispan{3}{\hfil {\bf Tak}}\hfil&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil {\bf Implementation}\hfil&&{\bf REAL}&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-Cray\hfil&&1.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-3081\hfil&&2.75&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda (M-C)\hfil&&4.75&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil S-1\hfil&&7.38&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil $3600+\hbox{IFU}$\hfil&&10.75&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 8600 CL\hfil&&11.25&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-20\hfil&&12.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Dorado\hfil&&13.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 3600\hfil&&14.75&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-780\hfil&&20.75&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil SAIL\hfil&&21.25&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750 (VMS)\hfil&&34.25&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 785 CL\hfil&&35.75&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-HP200\hfil&&38.25&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda\hfil&&40.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-DN300\hfil&&40.5&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Dandelion\hfil&&41.75&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750\hfil&&45.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 780 CL\hfil&&45.75&\cr\tablerule
}}$$
\vfill\eject
$$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
\def\tablerule{\noalign{\hrule}}
\halign {\bigstrut#& \vrule#\tabskip=1em plus2em&#& \vrule#&\hfil#\hfil&
\vrule#\tabskip=0pt\cr\tablerule
&&\multispan{3}\hfil {\bf Real Time} {\bf (Normalized)}\hfil&\cr
&&\multispan{3}{\hfil {\bf Stak}}\hfil&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil {\bf Implementation}\hfil&&{\bf REAL}&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-Cray\hfil&&1.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 8600 CL\hfil&&1.25&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-3081\hfil&&1.5&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Dorado\hfil&&1.67&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil $3600+\hbox{IFU}$\hfil&&2.04&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 3600\hfil&&2.28&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-20\hfil&&2.38&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 785 CL\hfil&&2.58&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 780 CL\hfil&&3.64&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil S-1\hfil&&3.81&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil SAIL\hfil&&3.91&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Dandelion\hfil&&4.12&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda (M-C)\hfil&&4.73&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 750 CL\hfil&&5.5&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 780 Franz (TrlOn \& LclfNo)\hfil&&5.59&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil InterLisp-10\hfil&&5.64&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda\hfil&&5.75&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-780\hfil&&6.28&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil LM-2\hfil&&6.93&\cr\tablerule
}}$$
\vfill\eject
$$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
\def\tablerule{\noalign{\hrule}}
\halign {\bigstrut#& \vrule#\tabskip=1em plus2em&#& \vrule#&\hfil#\hfil&
\vrule#\tabskip=0pt\cr\tablerule
&&\multispan{3}\hfil {\bf Real Time} {\bf (Normalized)}\hfil&\cr
&&\multispan{3}{\hfil {\bf Ctak}}\hfil&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil {\bf Implementation}\hfil&&{\bf REAL}&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-Cray\hfil&&1.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil S-1\hfil&&1.39&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-3081\hfil&&1.39&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 8600 CL\hfil&&3.93&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-20\hfil&&5.03&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil SAIL\hfil&&7.08&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda\hfil&&7.44&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil $3600+\hbox{IFU}$\hfil&&8.61&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-780\hfil&&9.12&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 785 CL\hfil&&9.78&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-DN160\hfil&&11.24&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 3600\hfil&&13.05&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 780 CL\hfil&&13.71&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Perq\hfil&&14.24&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-HP200\hfil&&15.81&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 750 NIL\hfil&&16.81&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil LM-2\hfil&&17.68&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 780 Franz (TrlOn \& LclfNo)\hfil&&20.42&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750 (VMS)\hfil&&20.47&\cr\tablerule
}}$$
\vfill\eject
$$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
\def\tablerule{\noalign{\hrule}}
\halign {\bigstrut#& \vrule#\tabskip=1em plus2em&#& \vrule#&\hfil#\hfil&
\vrule#\tabskip=0pt\cr\tablerule
&&\multispan{3}\hfil {\bf Real Time} {\bf (Normalized)}\hfil&\cr
&&\multispan{3}{\hfil {\bf Takl}}\hfil&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil {\bf Implementation}\hfil&&{\bf REAL}&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-Cray\hfil&&1.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-3081\hfil&&2.03&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 8600 CL\hfil&&6.77&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-20\hfil&&8.4&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil S-1\hfil&&9.73&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Dorado\hfil&&12.07&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil InterLisp-10\hfil&&12.6&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-DN160\hfil&&13.27&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil SAIL\hfil&&13.43&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil $3600+\hbox{IFU}$\hfil&&16.5&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-780\hfil&&17.57&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda (M-C)\hfil&&17.7&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 785 CL\hfil&&18.03&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-HP200\hfil&&19.1&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 3600\hfil&&21.5&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 780 CL\hfil&&24.47&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 780 Franz (TrlOn \& LclfNo)\hfil&&32.4&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil InterLispVax 780\hfil&&32.91&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda\hfil&&35.67&\cr\tablerule
}}$$
\vfill\eject
$$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
\def\tablerule{\noalign{\hrule}}
\halign {\bigstrut#& \vrule#\tabskip=1em plus2em&#& \vrule#&\hfil#\hfil&
\vrule#\tabskip=0pt\cr\tablerule
&&\multispan{3}\hfil {\bf Real Time} {\bf (Normalized)}\hfil&\cr
&&\multispan{3}{\hfil {\bf Takr}}\hfil&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil {\bf Implementation}\hfil&&{\bf REAL}&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-Cray\hfil&&1.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-3081\hfil&&2.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil $3600+\hbox{IFU}$\hfil&&7.17&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil S-1\hfil&&9.72&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 3600\hfil&&9.83&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-20\hfil&&9.83&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Dorado\hfil&&11.17&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 8600 CL\hfil&&13.5&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-780\hfil&&19.5&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil SAIL\hfil&&19.67&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Dandelion\hfil&&29.17&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-DN300\hfil&&29.17&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-HP200\hfil&&29.33&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda\hfil&&33.17&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 785 CL\hfil&&34.83&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750 (VMS)\hfil&&35.5&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil InterLisp-10\hfil&&36.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750\hfil&&47.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil LM-2\hfil&&47.83&\cr\tablerule
}}$$
\vfill\eject
$$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
\def\tablerule{\noalign{\hrule}}
\halign {\bigstrut#& \vrule#\tabskip=1em plus2em&#& \vrule#&\hfil#\hfil&
\vrule#\tabskip=0pt\cr\tablerule
&&\multispan{3}\hfil {\bf Real Time} {\bf (Normalized)}\hfil&\cr
&&\multispan{3}{\hfil {\bf Deriv}}\hfil&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil {\bf Implementation}\hfil&&{\bf REAL}&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-3081\hfil&&1.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-Cray\hfil&&1.11&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil S-1\hfil&&2.24&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-20\hfil&&3.08&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda (M-C)\hfil&&3.33&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda\hfil&&4.53&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-780\hfil&&4.79&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 8600 CL\hfil&&6.1&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil $3600+\hbox{IFU}$\hfil&&6.11&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-HP200\hfil&&6.65&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-DN160\hfil&&7.09&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 3600\hfil&&7.88&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750\hfil&&8.63&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Dorado\hfil&&10.09&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil InterLispVax 780\hfil&&10.36&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750 (VMS)\hfil&&10.45&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil LM-2\hfil&&10.72&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 750 NIL\hfil&&11.04&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 785 CL\hfil&&12.31&\cr\tablerule
}}$$
\vfill\eject
$$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
\def\tablerule{\noalign{\hrule}}
\halign {\bigstrut#& \vrule#\tabskip=1em plus2em&#& \vrule#&\hfil#\hfil&
\vrule#\tabskip=0pt\cr\tablerule
&&\multispan{3}\hfil {\bf Real Time} {\bf (Normalized)}\hfil&\cr
&&\multispan{3}{\hfil {\bf Dderiv}}\hfil&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil {\bf Implementation}\hfil&&{\bf REAL}&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-3081\hfil&&1.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-Cray\hfil&&1.12&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil S-1\hfil&&1.4&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-20\hfil&&3.46&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda (M-C)\hfil&&3.87&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda\hfil&&4.81&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-780\hfil&&5.3&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil $3600+\hbox{IFU}$\hfil&&6.02&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-HP200\hfil&&6.88&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-DN160\hfil&&7.19&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 3600\hfil&&7.83&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750\hfil&&10.02&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil LM-2\hfil&&10.16&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Dorado\hfil&&10.52&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750 (VMS)\hfil&&11.55&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 750 NIL\hfil&&12.45&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil InterLispVax 780\hfil&&12.86&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-DN300\hfil&&15.1&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil InterLisp-10\hfil&&15.96&\cr\tablerule
}}$$
\vfill\eject
$$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
\def\tablerule{\noalign{\hrule}}
\halign {\bigstrut#& \vrule#\tabskip=1em plus2em&#& \vrule#&\hfil#\hfil&
\vrule#\tabskip=0pt\cr\tablerule
&&\multispan{3}\hfil {\bf Real Time} {\bf (Normalized)}\hfil&\cr
&&\multispan{3}{\hfil {\bf Iterative Div2}}\hfil&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil {\bf Implementation}\hfil&&{\bf REAL}&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-3081\hfil&&1.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-Cray\hfil&&1.27&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil S-1\hfil&&1.82&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 8600 CL\hfil&&3.67&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-20\hfil&&5.11&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 785 CL\hfil&&7.47&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil InterLispVax 780\hfil&&8.36&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil $3600+\hbox{IFU}$\hfil&&9.87&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-780\hfil&&10.91&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 780 CL\hfil&&11.11&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 3600\hfil&&12.31&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda (M-C)\hfil&&13.11&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-HP200\hfil&&14.09&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda\hfil&&16.44&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-DN160\hfil&&16.64&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil LM-2\hfil&&19.18&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 750 NIL\hfil&&22.09&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750 (VMS)\hfil&&22.18&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750\hfil&&22.47&\cr\tablerule
}}$$
\vfill\eject
$$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
\def\tablerule{\noalign{\hrule}}
\halign {\bigstrut#& \vrule#\tabskip=1em plus2em&#& \vrule#&\hfil#\hfil&
\vrule#\tabskip=0pt\cr\tablerule
&&\multispan{3}\hfil {\bf Real Time} {\bf (Normalized)}\hfil&\cr
&&\multispan{3}{\hfil {\bf Recursive Div2}}\hfil&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil {\bf Implementation}\hfil&&{\bf REAL}&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-3081\hfil&&1.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-Cray\hfil&&1.43&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil S-1\hfil&&3.55&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-20\hfil&&5.57&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-DN160\hfil&&9.86&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-780\hfil&&11.48&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil $3600+\hbox{IFU}$\hfil&&13.14&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-HP200\hfil&&13.98&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda (M-C)\hfil&&14.52&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 3600\hfil&&15.88&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 8600 CL\hfil&&16.98&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil InterLispVax 780\hfil&&20.11&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 750 CL\hfil&&21.6&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda\hfil&&21.67&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750\hfil&&24.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil LM-2\hfil&&29.48&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Dorado\hfil&&30.38&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750 (VMS)\hfil&&30.5&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 785 CL\hfil&&35.48&\cr\tablerule
}}$$
\vfill\eject
$$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
\def\tablerule{\noalign{\hrule}}
\halign {\bigstrut#& \vrule#\tabskip=1em plus2em&#& \vrule#&\hfil#\hfil&
\vrule#\tabskip=0pt\cr\tablerule
&&\multispan{3}\hfil {\bf Real Time} {\bf (Normalized)}\hfil&\cr
&&\multispan{3}{\hfil {\bf FFT}}\hfil&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil {\bf Implementation}\hfil&&{\bf REAL}&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil S-1\hfil&&1.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil $3600+\hbox{IFU}$\hfil&&2.42&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 3600\hfil&&2.98&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Dorado\hfil&&3.18&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil SAIL\hfil&&6.49&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-3081\hfil&&7.83&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil InterLisp-10\hfil&&8.72&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda (M-C)\hfil&&9.78&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda\hfil&&11.05&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil InterLispVax 780\hfil&&15.77&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 8600 CL\hfil&&17.11&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Dolphin\hfil&&24.15&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 750 NIL\hfil&&26.42&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil LM-2\hfil&&27.04&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-20\hfil&&31.98&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Dandelion\hfil&&37.58&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Perq\hfil&&40.83&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 780 CL\hfil&&47.23&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-780\hfil&&51.21&\cr\tablerule
}}$$
\vfill\eject
$$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
\def\tablerule{\noalign{\hrule}}
\halign {\bigstrut#& \vrule#\tabskip=1em plus2em&#& \vrule#&\hfil#\hfil&
\vrule#\tabskip=0pt\cr\tablerule
&&\multispan{3}\hfil {\bf Real Time} {\bf (Normalized)}\hfil&\cr
&&\multispan{3}{\hfil {\bf Puzzle}}\hfil&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil {\bf Implementation}\hfil&&{\bf REAL}&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-Cray\hfil&&1.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-3081\hfil&&1.47&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil S-1\hfil&&1.83&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-HP200\hfil&&10.85&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil $3600+\hbox{IFU}$\hfil&&11.1&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil SAIL\hfil&&11.83&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 3600\hfil&&13.94&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Dorado\hfil&&14.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 8600 CL\hfil&&15.53&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-20\hfil&&15.92&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-780\hfil&&16.28&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda (M-C)\hfil&&24.35&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda\hfil&&29.3&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-DN160\hfil&&29.51&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-DN300\hfil&&31.74&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750 (VMS)\hfil&&31.84&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750\hfil&&35.93&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil LM-2\hfil&&42.93&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 780 CL\hfil&&47.48&\cr\tablerule
}}$$
\vfill\eject
$$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
\def\tablerule{\noalign{\hrule}}
\halign {\bigstrut#& \vrule#\tabskip=1em plus2em&#& \vrule#&\hfil#\hfil&
\vrule#\tabskip=0pt\cr\tablerule
&&\multispan{3}\hfil {\bf Real Time} {\bf (Normalized)}\hfil&\cr
&&\multispan{3}{\hfil {\bf Triang}}\hfil&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil {\bf Implementation}\hfil&&{\bf REAL}&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-Cray\hfil&&1.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-3081\hfil&&1.76&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil S-1\hfil&&4.3&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-20\hfil&&6.02&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 8600 CL\hfil&&6.91&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil $3600+\hbox{IFU}$\hfil&&8.08&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil SAIL\hfil&&10.03&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 3600\hfil&&10.51&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-780\hfil&&14.69&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda (M-C)\hfil&&15.62&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Dorado\hfil&&17.48&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-HP200\hfil&&18.08&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 780 CL\hfil&&24.99&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750 (VMS)\hfil&&30.44&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-DN300\hfil&&30.46&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 785 CL\hfil&&31.36&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Lambda\hfil&&35.35&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750\hfil&&36.23&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 750 NIL\hfil&&45.18&\cr\tablerule
}}$$
\vfill\eject
$$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
\def\tablerule{\noalign{\hrule}}
\halign {\bigstrut#& \vrule#\tabskip=1em plus2em&#& \vrule#&\hfil#\hfil&
\vrule#\tabskip=0pt\cr\tablerule
&&\multispan{3}\hfil {\bf Real Time} {\bf (Normalized)}\hfil&\cr
&&\multispan{3}{\hfil {\bf Fprint}}\hfil&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil {\bf Implementation}\hfil&&{\bf REAL}&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-3081\hfil&&1.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-Cray\hfil&&1.09&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil InterLispVax 780\hfil&&1.79&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 780 Franz (TrlOn \& LclfNo)\hfil&&1.79&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 8600 CL\hfil&&3.18&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 750 Franz (TrlOn \& LclfNo)\hfil&&3.62&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil SAIL\hfil&&3.88&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Franz 68000 (TrlOn \& LclfNo)\hfil&&4.21&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-DN160\hfil&&5.56&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-780\hfil&&6.44&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 785 CL\hfil&&6.82&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 3600\hfil&&7.94&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Dorado\hfil&&8.62&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750 (VMS)\hfil&&11.47&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 780 CL\hfil&&11.59&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-DN300\hfil&&12.32&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil InterLisp-10\hfil&&13.09&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-20\hfil&&14.03&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750\hfil&&15.68&\cr\tablerule
}}$$
\vfill\eject
$$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
\def\tablerule{\noalign{\hrule}}
\halign {\bigstrut#& \vrule#\tabskip=1em plus2em&#& \vrule#&\hfil#\hfil&
\vrule#\tabskip=0pt\cr\tablerule
&&\multispan{3}\hfil {\bf Real Time} {\bf (Normalized)}\hfil&\cr
&&\multispan{3}{\hfil {\bf Fread}}\hfil&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil {\bf Implementation}\hfil&&{\bf REAL}&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil InterLispVax 780\hfil&&1.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-3081\hfil&&3.12&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-Cray\hfil&&4.92&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 780 Franz (TrlOn \& LclfNo)\hfil&&11.56&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Dorado\hfil&&12.27&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil SAIL\hfil&&14.06&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 8600 CL\hfil&&18.28&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 750 Franz (TrlOn \& LclfNo)\hfil&&18.28&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Franz 68000 (TrlOn \& LclfNo)\hfil&&21.95&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-DN160\hfil&&24.14&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-780\hfil&&26.25&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 785 CL\hfil&&31.41&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil InterLisp-10\hfil&&34.92&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 3600\hfil&&35.94&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-HP200\hfil&&40.31&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-20\hfil&&45.47&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750 (VMS)\hfil&&48.44&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Dolphin\hfil&&50.08&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-DN300\hfil&&50.55&\cr\tablerule
}}$$
\vfill\eject
$$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
\def\tablerule{\noalign{\hrule}}
\halign {\bigstrut#& \vrule#\tabskip=1em plus2em&#& \vrule#&\hfil#\hfil&
\vrule#\tabskip=0pt\cr\tablerule
&&\multispan{3}\hfil {\bf Real Time} {\bf (Normalized)}\hfil&\cr
&&\multispan{3}{\hfil {\bf Tprint}}\hfil&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil {\bf Implementation}\hfil&&{\bf REAL}&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-Cray\hfil&&1.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-3081\hfil&&1.55&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 780 Franz (TrlOn \& LclfNo)\hfil&&2.6&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 8600 CL\hfil&&3.5&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 750 Franz (TrlOn \& LclfNo)\hfil&&4.35&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 785 CL\hfil&&7.7&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Franz 68000 (TrlOn \& LclfNo)\hfil&&8.25&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-DN160\hfil&&9.2&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-780\hfil&&9.6&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750 (VMS)\hfil&&13.15&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-DN300\hfil&&13.6&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 780 CL\hfil&&14.25&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 750 CL\hfil&&20.55&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-20\hfil&&21.25&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750\hfil&&21.4&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil InterLisp-10\hfil&&23.6&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 3600\hfil&&24.45&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Dorado\hfil&&27.75&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil SAIL\hfil&&32.6&\cr\tablerule
}}$$
\vfill\eject
$$\vbox{\tabskip=0pt \offinterlineskip
\def\tablerule{\noalign{\hrule}}
\halign {\bigstrut#& \vrule#\tabskip=1em plus2em&#& \vrule#&\hfil#\hfil&
\vrule#\tabskip=0pt\cr\tablerule
&&\multispan{3}\hfil {\bf Real Time} {\bf (Normalized)}\hfil&\cr
&&\multispan{3}{\hfil {\bf Tprint}}\hfil&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil {\bf Implementation}\hfil&&{\bf REAL}&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-Cray\hfil&&1.0&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-3081\hfil&&1.55&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 780 Franz (TrlOn \& LclfNo)\hfil&&2.6&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 8600 CL\hfil&&3.5&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 750 Franz (TrlOn \& LclfNo)\hfil&&4.35&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 785 CL\hfil&&7.7&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Franz 68000 (TrlOn \& LclfNo)\hfil&&8.25&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-DN160\hfil&&9.2&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-780\hfil&&9.6&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750 (VMS)\hfil&&13.15&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-DN300\hfil&&13.6&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 780 CL\hfil&&14.25&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 750 CL\hfil&&20.55&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-20\hfil&&21.25&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil PSL-750\hfil&&21.4&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil InterLisp-10\hfil&&23.6&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil 3600\hfil&&24.45&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil Dorado\hfil&&27.75&\cr\tablerule
&&\hfil SAIL\hfil&&32.6&\cr\tablerule
}}$$
\vfill\eject